What the devil is health?

by Captain Walker

Categories: Health, Humanities

Well, in case somebody expects a lecture on this, they have another thing coming! Today – in the midst of rapid acceleration of COVID-19 infections and deaths worldwide, I decide to ask a few people ‘What is health?‘ I’m a bit naughty, asking stupidly simple questions like that.

Not surprisingly respondents gave the following sorts of answers:

  1. Bodily health.
  2. Integrity of the body.
  3. Optimising body to its best.
  4. “It depends”
  5. Statements about what bad health is.

None of the respondents could put together a comprehensive picture of what health is, in less than 50 words. No single respondent included all of the above 4. No one thought of national health. Most people focused on bodily health. Only one respondent included something about mental health. One other of my colleagues who has mental health problems failed to include mental health upfront. RIDICULOUS!

I thought to myself, “This is crazy! Here we are in a ‘national health crises’ that is killing people left, right and centre – people are so concerned about health – and they can’t really give a clear picture of what health means.

So – I put together in a mindmap on how I conceptualise health. Be careful these are ‘big bones’, so if you don’t see your ‘aunties cheesecake’ on it – think harder! Did I say it was perfect? I did NOT! Is this advice for anyone? It is NOT! .. Oh.. oh.. OMG!! Stupid just got out! How?

STUPID: Hang on a sec.. you have a messed up sleep-wake cycle and you don’t exercise regularly, so who are you to lecture people on health!?

CW: You’re on a short leash. What I do with my health is nothing to do with the idea of what health is.

STUPID: Evasive.

CW: I did not say that everybody has to be 100% healthy in all their activities!

STUPID:  Making excuses for yourself – are you?

CW: No. I agree that that I could be healthier in many ways. Whatever I do wrong does not mean I am prohibited from talking about what I see health to be.

STUPID:  So you don’t practice what you preach?

CW:  WTF! I’m not preaching anything. What I practice has nothing to do with what health is?

STUPID:  So you want other people to do stuff that is healthy but you’re not gonna do all that is healthy?

CW: If you weren’t so thick as 10 planks you may have noticed that I was referring to health. I said nothing about people’s health. I said nothing about doing what is healthy.

STUPID:  Liar! You said ‘healthy relationships’. Don’t try to be clever.

CW: Yes I did. But I did not say anything about what is ‘healthy’.

STUPID: Really? Why?

CW: Simply because I’m not here to advise anybody on what to do to be ‘healthy’. I simply drew a mindmap of concepts that fall under health – and I said nothing about being healthy. I did not imply that all of the stuff in the mindmap will make people healthy.

STUPID: .. um…errh.. but.. I don’t.. get..hmmm.

CW:  What? Cat gotcha tongue? Right – time up.. back in the box. End of!

Disclaimer & Guidance

The reading of posts on this blog is subject to the Terms & Conditions. Unpalatable truths and personal experiences may be told. Nothing posted on this blog is directed at any identifiable person. Should any person or organisation reading this blog find something that makes them feel or know that they  are being referred to. Any such perceived identification is co-incidental – not factual. ‘Stupid‘ is an impish figment of my imagination who occasionally is allowed to pop up – and does not represent any known individual, individuals or groups. The treatment of  ‘Stupid‘ is not representative of the way people are treated in real life. Adverse inferences made are dismissed in advance.  














Other posts that may interest you...

Focalism and related biases

This bias is quite common. Have you ever been in a conversation where you make a thoughtful point, only to have the other person latch onto a single word or phrase and totally miss your intended meaning? This common phenomenon is known as focalism bias, and it can lead to frustrating misunderstandings and derailed discussions. ... Read more

Don’t bother to save 50% on your food bill.

Some people want to save money on food and some don’t. In my recent bill below I saved 69%. Obviously, I won’t get that saving every time. But the more savings I make; they will add up. It was on food that was reduced-price, around 16:30PM on a Sunday.  There are other days and times ... Read more

The Semmelweis Reflex

For quite some time I’ve been thinking that there must be a term to describe something I was observing over the last 25 years. Then I finally found it by accident today! This is not a lecture – just in case.  I found it in Bo Bennett’s book ‘Uncomfortable Ideas‘. Definition The Semmelweis reflex is ... Read more

Make your food stay longer..

I’m giving a few simple tips on making your cooked food last longer. Well no, you can’t eat it and have it – and this is not about eating more slowly. The short message is avoid as much as possible getting human spit or germs into your food. I’m not in the business of providing ... Read more

Continue reading

The Guarded Heart

This exploration may be a difficult one as the concept of the ‘Guarded Heart’ unfolds. References to love between man and woman also means love between two people of any orientation. This journey does not aim to provide solutions, answers, ...
Read article

Reading ability of UK doctors could be stuck at UK Year 9

Well, I do spend time on forums as some know to wrestle with parts of human nature that some totally avoid. Today I am led to infer that the reading ability of doctors in some significant proportion could be stuck ...
Read article

Painting with Emotions: A Colourful Journey into Love

Love between two hearts is a symphony of feelings, a dance that transforms the world around us. This journey we embark upon explores the tender bonds between a man and a woman, though the essence of love’s beauty may resonate ...
Read article