Placebo

by Captain Walker

Categories: Health, Science & Medicine

Placebo is the name of a band. I’m not interested in the band, in this post. This is about the nature of the placebo (and related) effects. I’m not giving a definition on this occasion. Readers can jump on the net and find whatever definitions they like.

I’m sharing some experience and knowledge of the placebo effects. Some will have references on the net, and some will not. My mission is not primarily to ‘explain’ the placebo effect, though I may touch on some possible mechanisms.

Description

The placebo effect is where a thing has the effect of improving something but it has no real efficacy. This can occur in human beings, organisations or systems. I have not asserted that it is a false effect. The positive effect is highly rewarding and creates an almost unshakeable belief that the ‘intervening thing’ is of value. Many will have missed the word ‘efficacy‘ or assumed what it meant.

Scenarios

Medication – a doctor says that s/he think you have condition X, prescribes a pill which he is fairly confident will improve the symptoms of the condition. You take this and after a few days you feel better. This means that the pill is working. That’s pretty simple. Ahhhh.. but after a further few weeks symptoms are not eradicated and actually grow worse. So now you think, maybe it wasn’t working that well. It is easy in the initial part of treatment for belief to be rewarded by improvement. Doubt sets in when symptoms return.

In Business – a company is having some problem with marketing a particular product. After a consultation exercise, they decide to implement some plan. Things improve over the next few months. They breath a sigh of relief – and conclude that their strategy was effective. They roll out the plan wider to the organisation, then in the next year it all goes pear shaped.

What’s happening there? In both there was expectation that the intervention would improve things. Following the intervention they concluded that the ‘treatment’ was effective. B followed A which led to causal thinking, instead of a deeper understanding of confounding variables. Some of those variables were missed and came back to bite.

In social life – people often report to each other that A, B, or C thing helped them with this or that problem. Numerous such reports are convincing – due to the herd effect. As I said elsewhere the herd effect is a powerful influencer from our psycho-evolutionary inheritance. So, individuals become convinced based on herd reports, then try A (for example) and get ‘symptom relief’. Expectation of relief (a psychological thing) could have driven the reduction in symptoms, while dangerous underlying pathology (for some) remained roaring below the surface (a sort of poultice effect). Powerful beliefs develop as a result of these social myths about ‘what’s good for what’. Any fool can jump on the internet and find a range of remedies for any ailment known to man (or woman) – from vaginal eggs to urine! Even prayer and exorcism can have placebo effects.

Mechanisms

Relief from physical or financial pain, is a powerful reward mechanism. It leads people to conclude that there is efficacy. In medical conditions the symptom, not unusually represents a deeper problem. I’m not talking about the common average headache here. The unusual recurring headache could be due to any one of dozens of serious conditions.

Similarly in business operations, a failure in one area may be connected to several other deeper complex problems. In other words the one has to be cautious not to rely on the ‘poultice’ effect.

People are naturally attracted to simplicity – everybody likes the simple and neat solution. This is why ‘pain relief’ is often taken as efficacy.

Dangers

I’m using ‘pain relief’ to cover a range of issues in medical complaints (of symptoms) and other scenarios. When you get that pain relief, you’re convinced that whatever it is that brought it will continue to work and work in the future. That’s fine for mild symptoms without underlying complexity or complications. But the average Joe or Jane won’t know what’s mild and uncomplicated until too late.

The first danger is of everybody turning into a hypochondriac – and rushing to GP’s surgeries demanding ‘X-rays’ and other tests. The next danger is being the exact opposite i.e. doing nothing.

The social value of some remedy – in the realm of myth – becomes pretty powerful. Hence, we see roaring debates between pure scientists and ‘the herd’ about the efficacy of homeopathy, chiropractic and alternative medicine. The way this works is that ‘some’ people will say that A, B, or C works for ‘some people’ some of the time. But even this does not mean efficacy. Again the word ‘works‘ is important to focus on, because what people really mean by that is symptom relief. They are certainly not talking about a ‘treatment’  or ‘intervention’ that targets the core of some pathological process.

But it gets more complicated because some of the alternative treatments become wrapped in a ‘quasi-science’ which is appealing and ‘makes sense’ – but still lacking in hard evidence of mechanism of aetiology or actual change in underlying pathology post-intervention. I will avoid going into each of those ‘alternative treatments’ which occupy my mind because I know it is a total waste of my time engaging in myth busting.

This post is not about ‘advice’, so I’m not here to tell people what to do.

Wrapping up

  1. The human mind can believe whatever it wants.
  2. Unconscious determinants of belief are numerous and can be powerful and risky.
  3. Seemingly conscious determinants of belief based for example on herd effects are equally risky.
  4. Symptom does not mean illness.
  5. Symptom relief does not mean effective treatment of an unseen underlying pathology.
  6. Quasi-science is attractive and dangerous.
  7. The placebo effect is powerful and dangerous.

Disclaimer & Guidance

The reading of posts on this blog is subject to the Terms & Conditions. Unpalatable truths and personal experiences may be told. Nothing posted on this blog is directed at any identified person. On occasions individuals are quoted anonymously. That does not mean that they have been identified to the world. Should any person or organisation reading this blog find something that makes them feel or know that they  are being referred to – any such perceived identification does not mean ‘identified to the world’. ‘Stupid‘ is an impish figment of my imagination who occasionally is allowed to pop up – and does not represent any known individual, individuals or groups. The treatment of  ‘Stupid‘ is not representative of the way people are treated in real life. Adverse inferences made are dismissed in advance.  


Other posts that may interest you...

Valdo Calocane: did he get away with murder?

The recent events on the sentencing of Valdo Calocane have led to public outcries. Mr Coates’ son James (a victim) said that Calocane had “made a mockery of the system“, adding that “he has got away with murder“. I have no relationship to the victims, their families, Calocane or the legal proceedings. This exploration will ... Read more

Complexities with medication

This is not a tutorial or advice. The infographic below is a broad-brush summary of some of the complex issues that need to be considered when prescribing medications. It is not exhaustive. This is not meant to be used by patients or the lay public to make decisions. It may serve as a template for ... Read more

Post-truth

If you’re looking for a lecture on ‘post-truth’, stop – then move on quickly to avoid wasting your time! I’ve been reading around the concept of post-truth for some time. I made passing mention of it here on 25th December 2019. There are several books on the topic, out there. I recently came across Lee ... Read more

The Burzynski Story: lessons in human nature

Dog-bathers are running for cover!! OMG! Like 3 hours of video? “No way!”, I hear them screaming as they zip off like The Roadrunner from Looney Tunes! ?? Or there is the other group who want everything in 5 words. GET LOST NOW! Well the shear stupidity of large systems and people in the above ... Read more