Present bias

by Captain Walker

Categories: Humanities, Psychology & Philosophy

If you’re looking for a tutorial depart now and save yourself time and bother. Instead head to Pure bias at Wikepedia and you’ll get your tutorial there. But if you stay on to read this post, you are warned as always that you’ll be putting up with my own thoughts about the concept (and the usual disclaimers apply).

What is present bias.

These are my thoughts. I don’t have to agree with everybody and/or various professors out there. The word ‘present’ instantly stands to connect to some issue about that nebulous place and time people call the future. If you have a bias about the present, then obviously you might get the ‘future’ wrong, in your forecasts or estimates about what may happen. Your plans for the future may not be as robust as you think because unknowingly – as are lots of biases – your thinking might be influenced in the wrong way. But you’re not going to know how wrong, until an unfortunate future unfolds for you. Then you’d beat yourself up – or pardon yourself – by saying “How stupid was I? Why couldn’t I have seen it before?

You can go on to read about ‘impulsivity‘, ‘procrastination‘ and ‘delayed gratification‘ that are associated by mechanism or side-effects, with the concept.

How it works

Everyday I see people making decisions about what may happen in the future. I often wonder how deeply they are thinking about their evidence. My observation is that most decisions in ordinary professional lives are made swiftly with just a few seconds or minutes of consideration. People do not have sufficient time to think deeply e.g. to consider:

  1. a range of competing issues.
  2. risk against historical evidence.
  3. impact of decisions for the distant future.

 Somebody needs an example. Let’s say you have person X who recently suffered with a mixed-manic and depressive phase of bipolar. X made what appeared to be a near full recovery and was discharged home and doing well at a follow-up clinic visit a few weeks later.  X was on lithium and olanzapine. Then there is a report that 3 weeks after the OPC visit, X is excessively sleepy (around 14 hours per day) and struggling on mornings. What do you do? The traditional approach is to say that the olanzapine at 12.5 mg orally per day is probably causing it (a swift decision or assessment in a team meeting without X present). And the follow on suggestion (aka decision) is either to try reducing the olanzapine or stop it for a while.

The non-traditional approach is to say: “Hold on he’s been on olanzapine 12.5mg for many many weeks without problems. Why is this happening now? Could there be something new happening like a relapse into a depressive phase?” One who is thinking deeply will say ‘Let’s not assume that this is due to olanzapine. Let’s get him in for a FTF review by his psychiatrist ASAP.” Stopping or reducing olanzapine  at that dose is not likely throw somebody into a manic illness if they are covered by lithium as well – and you don’t need to be a psychiatrist or doctor to know that.

But there are even deeper considerations. Like? A decision to reduce any treatment for any outpatient is subject to the law on consent (no references today – it just is). The correct standard is to see the patient understand their problems and then if necessary, with their consent reduce or stop the one that appears likely to be causing a problem. If you go “Yeah.. yeah.. consent means agreement” – then you know nothing about it but you don’t know that. You may wish to or not read the Mental Capacity Act.

If you’re moving swiftly, pathway A is your thing. If you’re me, pathway B is your thing.

What’s this got to do with ‘present bias’? It is about that immediate need to do something quickly – what they refer to as ‘impulsive’ based on information in front of you. The information is there now and people are influenced by it for seeming short term gains.

The roots of present bias

  1. When information is readily available, and it looks good.
  2. when there is pressure to make quick decisions, often times ‘trying to be helpful’.

Conclusion

I’m not here to tell people how to avoid present bias.  For me, I am just more vigilant of urges to act quickly based on what I see, and what I perceive in the moment. When people are clamouring for ‘action now’ and there is no real emergency I slow things down.

 

The reading of posts on this blog is subject to the Terms & Conditions. Unpalatable truths and personal experiences may be told. Nothing posted on this blog is directed at any identified person. On occasions individuals are quoted anonymously. That does not mean that they have been identified to the world. Should any person or organisation reading this blog find something that makes them feel or know that they  are being referred to - any such perceived identification does not mean 'identified to the world'. ‘Stupid' is an impish figment of my imagination who occasionally is allowed to pop up – and does not represent any known individual or individuals. ‘Stupid'  carries the characteristics groups of people with 'social media mindsets'. The treatment of  'Stupid' is not representative of the way people are treated in real life. Adverse inferences made are dismissed in advance. 

While the publisher and author have used their best efforts in preparing posts on this blog, they make no representation or warranties with respect to the accuracy or completeness of the contents  and specifically disclaim any implied warranties or fitness for a particular purpose. Posts on this blog do not contain all information available on various topics. Posts contain opinion based on facts, experience and other concepts. Opinions expressed are not advice nor intent on persuading any individual or other legal entity to adopt the opinions.  Posts are not created to be specific to any individual’s or organisation’s situation or needs. All persons are instructed to obey relevant policies and procedures that may apply to them. Departure from such, is at readers' own risk. You should consult with a professional with fiduciary duty to you, when making decisions. The author and publisher shall have no liability or responsibility to any person or entity regarding any loss or damage incurred, or alleged to have been incurred, directly or indirectly, by the information contained on this blog or hyperlinked from this blog. 


Other posts that may interest you...

The Futures game: exploiting the gap.

My venture into ‘derivatives’ – that evil thing associated with some ‘criminal’ bloke’- has led me to think a lot more about how we assess the future. By way of introduction, futures contracts – in the simplest form – are meant to agree  prices for various things in the future (e.g. oil, orange juice concentrate ... Read more

Is the future real?

The word ‘future’ has important meaning to human beings. I’m not about to do a thesis on what the word ‘future’ means. Look up for estimated reading time, if you have a dog to bathe. And I’m not interested in whether any particular reader has a dog or not! Definition A popular definition is to ... Read more

I found it

Well, I know that I do not throw away things that are/were of value to me. I found the book FALLACY: The counterfeit of argument,  in a storage box in my garage today 2022-05-29 around 12:30PM. It means I’ve kept that book for just over 40 years! Snapshots below. It is/was an important book because ... Read more

Living out the future..

It’s the greatest time to be alive!! And ‘time’ is of the essence. I recall 35 years ago as high-school kids we wondered almost weekly what the world would be like in 2010 (an important ‘landmark’ of the future for me). Well, I’m here! And the ‘future’ is great! Live video conferencing on handheld devices ... Read more

Continue reading

Reading ability of UK doctors could be stuck at UK Year 9

Well, I do spend time on forums as some know to wrestle with parts of human nature that some totally avoid. Today I am led to infer that the reading ability of doctors in some significant proportion could be stuck ...
Read article

Painting with Emotions: A Colourful Journey into Love

Love between two hearts is a symphony of feelings, a dance that transforms the world around us. This journey we embark upon explores the tender bonds between a man and a woman, though the essence of love’s beauty may resonate ...
Read article

The Throw-Away Person

In the canvas of human relationships, there exists a phenomenon that cuts to the core of our social nature – the experience of being a “throw away person”. This term describes individuals who find themselves unexpectedly and inexplicably cast aside ...
Read article